Featured Video
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Standards Features
Eric Cooper
Unspoken expectations are the hardest to meet
Ismael Belmarez
The updated safety standard, due out in May, brings ease of use to organizations seeking certification
Dirk Dusharme @ Quality Digest
Tech training, quality salaries, and read this, autonomous car!
Richard Harpster
Understanding ISO 9001:2015’s new requirement
Bruce Bolger
ISO human resources QMS standard creates significant opportunities for organizations

More Features

Standards News
Work with and learn from some of the nation’s best people and organizations
Ensuring that the system positively contributes to the organization’s bottom line is important
ISO 18295–1 and –2 include requirements for contact centers and for clients using centers services
3D CIC focuses on CAD collaboration and interoperability for the entire product life cycle
More than seven billion lives may depend on it
BYK-Gardner’s byko-spectra lite
Nominations accepted through June 30, 2017

More News

Denise Robitaille


ISO 9004 and Your Organization

Why we should care about sustainable success?

Published: Tuesday, August 25, 2009 - 04:00

The final draft of the revised ISO 9004 standard is out for ballot. This means that it will hopefully be available before the end of this year. It’s radically different from the last version. For one thing, the title has changed. It’s now: “Managing for the sustained success of an organization—A quality management approach.”

What’s so special about this new version? Why should we care? The answer to both of the questions is in the new title. We all have a vested interest in the notion of sustainable success. Particularly in these days of globalization and outsourcing, the importance of the sustainability of organizations is becoming increasingly apparent.

If you were to ask a supplier if they hope to be in around in six months and they responded: “No, we expect to close our doors within 90 days,” how would you feel about continuing to do business with them? You’d probably start shopping for a new supplier. Most organizations don’t deliberately conduct themselves in such a way as to ensure their premature demise. But many times they fail to pay adequate attention to trends in the market, to fluctuations in raw material availability, to amendments to laws and statutes, to the emergence of new technologies, or to changes within their own four walls. They don’t notice that lead times from suppliers are getting uniformly longer or that customers may be giving them repeat orders but are not inviting them to bid on new projects. They don’t take the time to periodically assess their organization’s status and performance.

That’s what the new ISO 9004 standard is all about. It moves an organization beyond simple conformance to a management system, to a level of maturity that facilitates its ability to anticipate and respond to change.

Why should we all care about ISO 9004? Because the integrity of our supply chains is inexorably linked to the robustness of our suppliers’ management systems. Suppliers who aren’t committed to establishing and maintaining systems that espouse the practices of monitoring their environment (both internal and external) and taking appropriate action will eventually cease to be able to meet your needs. This in turn means that as their systems unravel or become obsolete you will have diminished ability to serve your customers’ needs.

Consider how costly it is to deal with the consequences of late delivery. Think about the drain on your resources as you rework sub-standard parts or sort through batches looking for the anticipated defective components. Or, calculate the expenditure to find and qualify a new supplier. There’s the initial research, the multiple calls and requests for samples. There may be one or two visits, followed by a supplier qualification audit. Then there are trial runs of material or probationary periods for service. Finally, you’re able to qualify the new supplier and add them to the ubiquitous Approved Vendor List. How much money has been lost from the moment you realized you were going to have to find a new source for a critical part?

In Out of the Crisis (Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1982), W. Edwards Deming discusses the folly of buying on price alone. We should be attentive to our suppliers and to the many varied factors that affect their continued ability to serve us.

It is more cost effective to monitor the existing suppliers and (when appropriate) to partner with them for improvement so as to ensure their continued ability to respond to changing demands in the market place. One of the tools you can use is ISO 9004. Use it as an assessment benchmark for your organization as well as your suppliers. Teach them how to use the assessment tools.

ISO 9004 creates the tangible link between the seemingly esoteric requirements of ISO 9001 and that which ultimately matters to an organization. It illustrates how those requirements, by promoting the sustainable success of the organization and using the guidance from both standards, allows the organization to achieve both its own goals and those of its customers.

Organizations who deal with multiple tiers of suppliers should endorse both ISO 9001 and ISO 9004 right down the line. It’s the domino effect in reverse. Rather than causing the next tile to fall, we establish systems that ensure that we all continue to stand. The better your suppliers are the better a supplier you will be to your customers.


About The Author

Denise Robitaille’s picture

Denise Robitaille

Denise E. Robitaille is a member of the U.S. TAG to ISO/TC 176, the committee responsible for updating the ISO 9000 family of standards. She is committed to making your quality system meaningful. Through training, Robitaille helps you turn audits, corrective actions, management reviews, and processes of implementing ISO 9001 into value-added features of your company. She’s an RABQSA-certified lead assessor, ASQ-certified quality auditor, and ASQ Fellow. She’s the author of numerous articles and several books, including The Corrective Action Handbook and The Preventive Action Handbook, and a co-author of The Insider’s Guide to ISO 9001:2008, all published by Paton Professional.


ISO 9004

The Article "ISO 9004 and Your Organization" provides the information that the new version is radically different from the last version. Even title of the standard has been changed.

Now the article has created a desire to know what are new points. I am interested to read more articles on this.

With regards,

Keshav Ram Singhal, Ajmer (India)

Last version of 9004

Wasn't the 2000 version of 9004 significantly different from the 1994 one? (I'm hesitate to use the word "radically," but it seemed very different to me.) Maybe I am thinking of another of the ISO 9000 documents, but, in 2000, the number was substantially reduced so that I am relatively sure 9004 is what I am thinking of.

Last version of 9004

Yes, the 2000 version of 9004 was significantly different form 1994. With the 2009 revision, they've made even more changes -- unlike the minimal changes to 9001. Also, although it is still complementary to 9001, it no longer has the same structure and does not contain the complete text of 9001.

Posted by admin on behalf of Denise Robitaille