Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Quality Insider Features
Aron Solomon
When minimum isn’t enough
Ian Williamson
Bosses need to get used to it
David Gillum
There’s no central reporting system in the U.S. or internationally
The Un-Comfort Zone With Robert Wilson
These tips will help you with your fear of success
Nate Burke
To improve your brand, review how to make the returns experience better

More Features

Quality Insider News
Applications close Monday, January 10, 2022
Designed for process cooling applications including industrial cooling circuits
New features enable manufacturers to launch products faster with lower overall cost and fewer errors
Control System Integrators Association’s certification program demonstrates dedication to continuous improvement
New grooving tools optimized to enable lighter cutting action and reduced cutting forces
New president brings two decades of executive leadership to metrology manufacturer
Newly independent LRQA business brings together expertise in certification, cybersecurity, inspection, and training

More News

Quality Insider

Who Studies Quality Management in High School?

These children may know more about quality than your managers

Published: Monday, May 21, 2012 - 10:16

There is a remarkable quality movement afoot centered in South Asia with tentacles that reach to the United States, Europe, and Africa.

Starting in primary school and extending throughout high school, students are introduced to the teachings of W. Edwards Deming, Joseph Juran, Philip Crosby, Kaoru Ishikawa, and many other great figures of quality. They learn quality problem-solving tools, basic kaizen, 5S, benchmarking, and a host of East/West theories about human development and motivation.

I saw this with my own eyes. This three-minute video clip of these young students says it all.

This movement is centered in the city of Lucknow in northern India. With a population of nearly three million, it’s India’s 12th largest city. Home to the movement is City Montessori School, which, with its 40,000 students, is the world’s largest school in pupils, per the Guinness Book of World Records. Dr. Jagdish Gandhi and his wife, Mrs. Bharti Ghandi, founded it in 1959 and began including quality concepts in their curriculum during the 1990s, as they saw what Japan had accomplished.

The annual convention

Jagdish Gandhi’s teachings have spread throughout India and various parts of the world, in particular the neighboring South Asia nations of Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Nepal, and—due to its close ties with “Mother India”—the African island of Mauritius. The teachings are shared primarily via an annual convention called the “International Convention on Students’ Quality Control Circles (ICSQCC). It’s held regularly in Lucknow but has also been in Houston, Singapore, Katmandu, and Mauritius. In 2014 it’s scheduled to be held at London’s Kingston University.

https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/MukrcChcvbpT8X1tMclcW63T3gmBndZi72v1Fh3apdRqKj2_lICRAYPvp_41lepYqnNArCxrcX7matWbxcxD27HwML7KbAO7q775WJZvmJm9a4sLn4Y
Jagdish Gandhi at the opening festivities of the ICSQCC 2012

The convention is an opportunity for the best teams to showcase their prowess at quality improvement, and promote a culture of quality through art, drama, and dance. Additionally, several international speakers from all continents attend to present to the students and faculty in attendance the latest ideas on topics that are connected to quality in some way.

The team competitions are a blood sport. Students take their competitions so seriously, the final night’s award banquet is filled with emotions equal to a night at the Oscars. Tears of crushing disappointment for a loss and shrieks of joy to win one of many awards provide the setting for the evening. As you can see, these kids were dressed for the event!

https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/YKVME6x1bRseg8QpX2W_GE96MFKq32C6o9othyyKkQdoiumNw4gxrpfnLi7m046LrHcJ8u0Pt6fNGwJoovthLqrIALhQATa9xcAFZTcVCxVMX0gFrKg

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/BIM_0FmVuZ12iPsC7nlduLC3jVbI-YBCKq-35olxJve6YVGinrDAYwALok-ddQlRjOlwvdTMTguI0V6fCsMQX06jSKE1ls1NoCRhIUpYqdlwCh-BAlU
Delighted student teams claiming their competition awards during the ICSQCC 2012 closing celebration.

The convention itself is a huge production, and Gandhi is able to attract some regional star power. The 2011 guest of honor was one of the Prime Ministers from Sri Lanka. In 2009 it was the President of Mauritius. Not bad for a high school competition.

For the students from India, given the backdrop of India’s economic rise, one can only wonder what fantastic career paths there will be for these future leaders when they infuse the vigor of their childhood training in quality into their country’s industrial bloodstream.

One team’s project: dung

One of the many remarkable projects belonged to the team that solved the problem of the poor health of the school’s milk-producing cows. (There’s a farm that’s attached to the school to help supply food for the students, teachers, laborers, and community). A seemingly intractable problem, the students nonetheless took it on. They started with a proper definition of the problem, then collected data as to the magnitude of the underlying issues, and stratified the available data. When they needed more, they took samples—statistically valid, mind you—of cow dung to test for parasites, and coordinated with a lab for analysis. Then the team went on to investigate causes, analyze possible solutions, and perform tests. It was a magnificent demonstration of so many aspects of quality management—and yes, the cows returned to good health and a productive life.

Of course, there was the question that I couldn’t resist asking after their results were unveiled: “What did the farm manager have to say about all this?” The students’ eyes raced to each other in a moment of discomfort. “Well, sir, we tried to make him part of the solution.” They also teach tact at this school.

A child’s commitment

Don’t be fooled into thinking these children are simply parroting the quality exhortations of their masters. Quite the contrary: They embrace these teachings. They are not converts—they are disciples. The intensity with which these kids speak of becoming a “total quality person” leaves you a bit choked up.

What we saw was a refreshing young class of future leaders. There is little doubt that their early grounding in quality philosophy and tools will strongly influence how they will one day lead, and live.

“Sir, quality is not a matter of chance; it is a matter of choice.”
—Student at the ICSQCC 2011 convention

Discuss

About The Authors

Jeff Dewar’s picture

Jeff Dewar

Jeff Dewar is CEO of Millennium 360 Inc., Quality Digest’s parent company. During his career he has presented quality-related topics to thousands of people on six continents, all but Antarctica.

Kristine Bammert’s picture

Kristine Bammert

Kristine Bammert is Director of Operations at Millennium 360 Inc., Quality Digest’s parent company. Prior to this, she spent two decades in the avionics industry, implementing advanced training systems across the globe that focused on quality and performance-based outcomes.

Comments

Competing for the awards

Hi Ed, thanks for the comment. And then there's the Deming Prize, and we all know the competition that surrounds it.

Why make competition of Deming, et al.?

I was cheering and saying, “Yes!  Yes!  How wonderful!”

Then I read: The team competitions are a blood sport. Students take their competitions so seriously, the final night’s award banquet is filled with emotions equal to a night at the Oscars. Tears of crushing disappointment for a loss and shrieks of joy to win one of many awards provide the setting for the evening.”

Now I feel some sorrow and say: How sad.

Why make competition of Deming, et al.?  Why deliberately set out to create as few “winner” children as possible and as many “loser” children as possible?  Why artificially constrain the possibilities?

High on Advt

It is good if such schools really believe in what they are doing - there is no need to have high profile garlanding ceremonies . This is is a typical malaise affecting organizations in India . It is enough if children are taught to practice this in day to day life . If you goaround Lucknow and in Uttar Pradesh in general , you will be compelled to report a different sotry

Thanks

Dear Mr.Jeff and Ms.Kritine

Iam proud of those childern who have participated in this work.You are right,in our country ,the basics of quality culture is tought at the teen age itself.The problem is the internalisation of the same and using this concept once they join an industry.I think this is where we are lacking.

Thanks for this article where you have exposed my country's basic culture to whole world!

 

Regards

 

Aravind