Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Quality Insider Features
Chris Fox
Rediscovering the mother of all innovation—necessity
Grant Ramaley
Verify ISO QMS certificates using the International Accreditation Forum (IAF) CertSearch database
Drew Calvert
Should firms be required to disclose the negative social impacts of their suppliers?
Innovating Service With Chip Bell
When customers release their imagination to resolve a problem, everyone benefits
MIT News
They can quickly learn to optimize building microclimates for both energy consumption and user preference

More Features

Quality Insider News
An advanced wireless data collection system for acquiring precision measurement data
Realistic variations in glossiness could aid fine art reproduction and the design of prosthetics
All of the manufacturer’s X-ray sources are supported including rotating target technology and 450kV microfocus source
Smart manufacturing includes recyclability and energy and waste reduction, leading to sustainability and cost savings
Ideal for measuring large components or multiple small components, quickly, easily, and accurately
Measure workpieces from 25 mm to 42.5 mm with a measuring range of ±100 µm and a repeatability of ≤0.1 µm
Contactless gauging system for measuring steel wire for tires, copper wire for electrical cables, CO2 welding wire, and more
Too often process enhancements occur in silos where there is little positive impact on the big picture

More News

Angelo Lyall

Quality Insider

What Successful Strategies Have in Common

Keys to designing a strategy

Published: Wednesday, June 15, 2011 - 04:30

Clarity is extremely valuable for building profitable strategies and conducting sustainable business. Without clarity many firms refrain from taking strategic steps in fear of the unknown, leaving them stagnant and eventually uncompetitive. Only by understanding the key concepts that underpin successful strategies, can a firm confidently take steps along the strategic pathway of their choice.

The profitability of an organization’s strategy is a function of:
1. Strategic decisions made in favor of cost, benefit, or niche provision
2. Operational execution of the strategy


Given these variables, I have created what I call the “Strategic Profitability Frontier Curve” (see figure 1) to visually understand a firm’s position on the competitive landscape and plot it in relation to its key competitors.

Figure 1: Strategic Profitability Frontier Curve

Note that a niche provider is a unique position in which a firm combines specialized benefit advantages with the cost advantages of experience and economies of scale.

Strategic decisions depend on a firm’s ability to translate market knowledge into innovative (i.e., unique) tactics involving the product, service, price, brand image, promotion, and processes required to maximize their return on investment. Execution is the extent to which a strategy’s elements are successfully implemented. Given that marketing and innovation are the key functions required for success, firms must be committed and passionate about both. The absence of either function can be crippling in the long term.

The importance of marketing and innovation within a firm is shown in the matrix in figure 2, using the simple metaphor of a car.

Figure 2: Sustainability matrix

Worn tires: With worn tires, a vehicle has limited traction. Without adequate marketing, a business may use its innovative skills to develop products, services, and processes that ultimately fail to deliver value to their customers and fail to produce adequate return on the investment. The lesson in this case is that businesses must not only do things right, but they must also be sure that they are doing the right things.

Broken-down vehicle: A broken-down vehicle does not move. In the simultaneous absence of marketing and innovation, a firm is left standing still in a race, competing against other firms that will inevitably overtake its position. This is the least favorable position on the matrix.

Running on fumes: A vehicle running on fumes may be moving forward based on momentum, but it can only continue to do so based on that momentum because it has no gas left to create more power. Without an effective, innovative presence in a firm, it is left to marketing to fight an uphill battle of building brand image and incentive programs to compensate for the firm’s inability to keep current and relevant.

Race ready: A race-ready vehicle is one that has a full tank of gas, and working parts. A business that has effective marketing and innovative functions has the ingredients for long-term sustainability.

Is your business race ready? Is it fully committed to marketing and innovation so that it may combine informed strategic decisions with differentiating tactics to generate profit? If the answer to either of these questions is no, then this must be reconciled before making an organized effort to compete and attain long-term sustainability and profit. I strongly urge all businesses to focus on building a deep understanding of marketing.


About The Author

Angelo Lyall’s picture

Angelo Lyall

Business Economist Angelo Lyall is a partner with Anderson Lyall Consulting Group, a Toronto-based consulting and advisory firm that helps firms develop their competitive advantage. He draws upon his background in economics and competitive strategy to help firms build profitable competitive strategies, business models and marketing plans, as well as to gain valuable market knowledge. Lyall helps companies understand and gain new insights into their business environment in order to create or strengthen competitive advantages. He has advised clients in the manufacturing, service, and distribution industries on issues of competitive strategy, marketing, pricing, and customer profitability.