Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Management Features
Gleb Tsipursky
Returning to the office harms diversity
Meridith Wentz
A follow-up conversation with organizational leaders  
Alexander Mirza
A wake-up call for hotel CEOs
Corey Binns
How a growth mindset can boost happiness at work
Megan Wallin-Kerth
Good leaders share seven qualities, says the founder of Rogue Valley Microdevices

More Features

Management News
Gartner survey reveals how organizations are developing their use of AI
While many executives believe themselves immune, research says otherwise.
Tactics aim to improve job quality and retain a high-performing workforce
Increases Xcelerator capabilities for climate-neutral aviation
Demonstrating a commitment to keeping people safe and organizations running
Sept. 28–29, 2022, at the MassMutual Center in Springfield, MA
EPM service provider excels in helping customers work with EPM products
It’s not exactly a labor shortage

More News

Timothy F. Bednarz

Management

Assessing Employee Growth and Development

A performance review serves a twofold purpose

Published: Thursday, October 4, 2012 - 13:24

Effective leaders manage by keeping their finger on the pulse of their employees’ key activities. When tasks and assignments are delegated, leaders must take the time to review each employee’s progress against goals to determine what, if any, additional training and coaching is needed to successfully complete the assignment or enhance the employee’s skills.

An assignment performance review serves a twofold purpose. Leaders receive a progress report on the delegated task or assignment. They allow the employee to provide details and input on what has happened to date, and the results. The employee is also providing feedback on any problems, issues, and concerns that may have surfaced. This allows the leader to provide insights and suggest possible courses of action, if needed.

The second purpose is to assess professional employee growth and skill development. Properly performed, an assignment performance review allows leaders to guide and direct the professional development of their employees. This is the most important aspect of the review.

The purpose of delegation is not only to assign tasks and assignments, but also to build and polish an employee’s skills and capabilities. Only when this happens can leaders know with confidence that tasks and assignments can be successfully delegated, and overall performance and results increased.

When leaders monitor an employee’s performance, they are performing a mixture of a work and planning review with a developmental planning review.

A work and planning review directs and controls the employee’s performance in the traditional management sense, while a developmental planning review assists the employee in improving his personal skills. When reviewing the progress of a delegated assignment or task, the leader is doing both.

During an assignment performance review, the leader is reviewing the actual progress toward the employee’s specific goals while also assessing her knowledge, attitude, and on-the-job skills. During the review, leaders are not controlling and directing but seeking balanced input from the employee. In this manner, problems, issues, and concerns are discussed while the leader asks questions to identify the degree to which the employee has worked to resolve them. Leaders provide their insight or advice only after employees have given a full report of their progress, the problems and issues that have arisen, and the various alternatives they have tried.

Throughout performance assessments, leaders need to build trust and rapport with their employees to develop deeper levels of loyalty. There are several things leaders need to avoid so the relationship with their employee is not undermined during these reviews. These include:

Unwarranted criticism

Leaders should base their judgments and criticisms on facts, not supposition. They must avoid making unwarranted negative comments or judgments about the employee’s performance, attitude, and decisions.

Analyzing the employee’s motivation

Leaders should avoid playing the role of amateur psychiatrist and not analyze an employee’s motives or behaviors.

Controlling and directing

Leaders should avoid giving a detailed solution to existing problems without first asking employees for their input.

Threatening and coercion

Because leaders are using delegation to develop employee skills, they should avoid at all costs any attempts to coerce and force an employee to do things their way. They should avoid threatening employees with intimidating and negative consequences.

Questioning

Leaders should avoid second-guessing their employees with questions about every idea, decision, recommendation, or suggestion. The purpose of the performance review is to analyze performance regarding a delegated task and to assess how employee skills have improved.

Once the initial phase of the review has been performed and the assignment thoroughly discussed, the leader and employee should agree on an action plan for the remaining portions of the project. The leader should include any plans for self-improvement and growth the employee may require, which may include additional training or coaching in specific skill areas.

Whatever the actual plans, leaders should make sure they are realistic, attainable, measurable, and on a scheduled timeline. Both the leader and the employee should know what will be done and how, and detailed milestones that the employee needs to achieve must be set.

Discuss

About The Author

Timothy F. Bednarz’s picture

Timothy F. Bednarz

Timothy F. Bednarz, Ph.D., is an accomplished author, researcher, consultant, entrepreneur, and innovator. He has founded three successful companies and has more than 26 years consulting experience in business development. As a critical thinker and transformational agent of change, he has the ability to view complex issues, identifying specific causes to develop meaningful solutions in simple terms. He has authored more than 125 books as well as a wide variety of high quality learning content. His latest book is Great! What Makes Leaders Great (Majorium Business Press, 2012). He is the author of more than 85 books in the Pinpoint Skill Development Training Series.