Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Lean Features
Rachel Gordon
New algorithm is accurate, efficient, and adaptable for complex, real-world assemblies
Sue Via
A lean management road map
Brian Brooks
We talk prevention, but do detection
Bhushan Avsatthi
In future-ready infrastructure, BIM will lead the way
William A. Levinson
The AIAG offers a clearly defined and powerful synergy between the three

More Features

Lean News
Quality doesn’t have to sacrifice efficiency
Weighing supply and customer satisfaction
Specifically designed for defense and aerospace CNC machining and manufacturing
From excess inventory and nonvalue work to $2 million in cost savings
Tactics aim to improve job quality and retain a high-performing workforce
Sept. 28–29, 2022, at the MassMutual Center in Springfield, MA
Enables system-level modeling with 2D and 3D visualization, reducing engineering effort, risk, and cost
It is a smart way to eliminate waste and maximize value
Simplified process focuses on the fundamentals every new ERP user needs

More News

Jim Benson


The Fundamental Problem With Business Process

You can’t set up an operational imperative and have someone else meaningfully improve it

Published: Monday, June 11, 2018 - 11:02

Let’s take a second to emphasize who is important in the following quotes, all by W. Edwards Deming:If you can’t describe what you are doing as a process, you don’t know what you are doing.” “A bad system will beat a good person every time.”Drive fear from the workplace.

Well, by golly, it’s people.

Deming again:A company could put a top man at every position and be swallowed by a competitor with people only half as good, but who are working together.”

W. Edwards Deming, the internationally renowned consultant whose work led Japanese industry into new principles of management and revolutionized its quality and productivity

As long as we see process as something other than how we agree to work, “process” will always be a tool of the uninformed to try to force the people actually doing the work to meet targets those in control assume to be important. We will continue to buy our “process” from books or consultants. We will have our “process” foisted on us.

But there is a difference between process and operational imperatives.

Operational imperatives are uninformed ways of working that we learn in classrooms or are poorly described in corporate manuals that come from outside the team. They are only improvable by management because management owns them. Continuous improvement or an improvement mindset can only be held by those who have a burning desire to improve. All others will quietly toil under the regime. Stagnation and isolation will ensue.

Process, as Deming was describing it, is the social contract your teams and your organization agree upon to provide value. They define it, they engage it, and they improve it. Process is intentional. If a process does not include a way to improve itself, it will not improve. If a process does not directly address quality, you will have shoddy product. If a process does not have a mechanism to connect with the customer, you will lose focus on customer needs. If process is not owned by the people engaged in the process, it is not process—it’s orders.

Let me be clear: If you implement ways of working that the effected people don’t have a hand in defining, you are setting up an operational imperative. That can and does work. It’s your choice. But know that you can’t set up that system and call it lean. You can’t up an operational imperative and have someone else meaningfully improve it.

You also can’t start with an operational imperative (even if it’s super cool or accepted as an industry standard) and expect any of Deming’s warnings not to come true.

The act of “describing your work as a process” does not mean you can say, “I take this goop and form it into that shape and dry it in that hot box and put it in that container for shipping.” Your phone can say that. But why is it different?

Deming didn’t just say “describe your work as a process;” he also talked a lot about collaboration and constancy of purpose. In other words, describing your work as a system means you understand not just the value stream of your work—any robot can do that. You need to understand that your process isn’t just mechanics, it’s psychology, it’s interaction, it’s invention, it’s improvement. Why we are doing this. For whom we are doing this. With whom we are doing this.

A process is how we express being human.

To make our process into a simple value stream is to cheapen all human endeavor and ultimately create bad systems in which to trap good people. It leads us into Jack Welch firing the alleged “bottom 20 percent.” It leads to process fads and certifications based on someone’s assumption of how work happens but never really fits any specific company. It leads to reliance on outside voices, rather than taking responsibility for our own future. It leads to industry “best-practices” rather than optimization for our own context. It leads to wasting time, energy, and money on forced solutions that are expensive to change, rather than democratic solutions that change naturally.

Business process, therefore, is the combination of your system of work, your culture, and your relationships with customers and suppliers. Given that your working methods, how you interact internally, and how you supply value are what your company does... if you can’t describe these as a “process,” then you don’t know what you are doing.

First published on the Modus Cooperandi blog.


About The Author

Jim Benson’s picture

Jim Benson

Jim Benson is the creator and co-author (with Tonianne DeMaria) of the best seller Personal Kanban (Modus Cooperandi Press, 2011) winner of the Shingo Research and Publication Award, 2013. His other books include Why Limit WIP (Modus Cooperandi, 2014), Why Plans Fail (Modus Cooperandi, 2014), and Beyond Agile (Modus Cooperandi Press, 2013). He is a winner of the Shingo Award for Excellence in Lean Thinking, and the Brickell Key Award. Benson and DeMaria teach online at Modus Institute and consult regularly, helping clients in all verticals create working systems. Benson regularly keynotes conferences, focusing on making work rewarding and humane.


Reading your article 1st thing in the morning

Reading your article first thing in the morning wasn't the best idea that I've ever had. But it did start the cogs moving. It was concise. And I could say too concise. But on the other hand, if you began to elaborate on any of the article's elements, you'd have a 300 page book before you could blink. One element that I would like to elaborate is the human factor. Having already been in the Quality field more than 30 years, I've came up with my own basics more than 20 years ago. And they go something like this....... When a new worker comes to me for his introductory training session, I tell them this, "If you respect your workplace and the product that you are working on, 90% of my job is done. The other 10% I can teach you with ease". This message has been relayed to every single worker, from CEOs, Vice Presidents to every production worker. I'm not saying that it's 100% foolproof but it's pretty close. This is part of the basic building blocks of building a successful business.