Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Innovation Features
Daniel Croft
Noncontact scanning for safer, faster, more accurate, and cost-effective inspections
National Physical Laboratory
Using Raman spectroscopy for graphene and related 2D materials
Ashley Hixson
Partnership with Hexagon’s Manufacturing Intelligence division provides employable metrology skills
Annual meeting in Phoenix, April 26–28
Krysten Crawford
Stanford researchers designed a program to accelerate hiring for minorities and women

More Features

Innovation News
Alliance will help processors in the US, Canada, and Mexico
New features revolutionize metrology and inspection processes with nondimensional AI inspection
Strategic partnership expands industrial machining and repair capabilities
Supports robots from 14 leading manufacturers
AI designed to improve productivity and processes
Ultrasonic flaw detector now has B/C scan capability, improved connectivity, and an app to aid inspection
Tapping tooz for AR/VR competence center
Provides opportunities to deepen leadership capabilities

More News

Barbara A. Cleary


Juggling Balls

Improving products, watching the world

Published: Tuesday, June 13, 2017 - 12:02

In a 1995 interview, tech guru Steve Jobs posited that empires could crash and burn if the emphasis is on sales rather than on product. “Companies forget what it means to make great products,” he said. Instead, they direct resources to selling, rather than improving and innovating.

If empires can crash and burn with this approach, what about organizations? A classic story tells of a company with a great innovation that customers clamor for; but the company, intent on advertising and promoting its product, loses sight of possibilities to improve it, and eventually sales drop in spite of increased advertising budgets, and the company goes bankrupt.

Improvement comes not only with a consistent focus on quality, but also with an eye on what else is happening in the world. This demands consistent contact with customers and competitors, as well as a professional interest in economic forces that may have an impact on businesses.

The inventor of the Veg-O-Matic slicer-and-dicer basked in record sales generated by television advertising, and energetic product demonstrations by Ron Popeil. The company apparently didn’t see the food processor coming, nor anticipate that the Veg-O-Matic, like the dinosaurs before it, would disappear from the face of the earth—or at least from most kitchens with new appliances on the counter—except as “vintage” products on used-goods sites. Purveyors of the new eight-track audio tapes were vanquished by cassette tapes, then CDs, and they in turn by digital downloads. The oft-touted manufacturer of classic, high-quality buggy whips must have failed to see that transportation was changing, and that the emerging automobiles wouldn’t be needing buggy whips, regardless of the whips’ quality.

Making great products, then, involves far more than just manufacturing a product and selling it. Innovators must be looking constantly to the future, not only to assure the continuous improvement of their products, but also to see market changes, understand changing customer needs, and foster the ability to respond to forces outside their control.

Addressing two kinds of problems (“problems of today; problems of tomorrow”) W. Edwards Deming’s 14 Points for Management emphasizes the importance of “constancy of purpose,” which supports the chain reaction: improve quality, reduce costs, improve productivity, capture the market, stay in business, provide jobs and more jobs. Deming insisted on the necessity of innovation as part of this constancy of purpose. Innovating involves looking ahead and perceiving potential changes in the market by taking the pulse of customers and those who identify future trends. See pages 2–3 in Deming’s book Out of Crisis.

It’s a full-time job to be sure, all this looking around and anticipating what’s to come. But companies who stay in touch with their customers, not by press-one-for-service responses or anonymous polls, but through genuine interactions about their work, find themselves seeing what these customers may identify as “wants,” and transforming these wants into needs by producing high quality products that respond to future needs as well as current wants.

It’s a far more exciting prospect than that of crashing and burning.


About The Author

Barbara A. Cleary’s picture

Barbara A. Cleary

Barbara A. Cleary, Ph.D., is a teacher at The Miami Valley School, an independent school in Dayton, Ohio, and has served on the board of education in Centerville, Ohio, for eight years—three years as president. She is corporate vice president of PQ Systems Inc., an international firm specializing in theory, process, and quality management. She holds a masters degree and a doctorate in English from the University of Nebraska. Cleary is author and co-author of five books on inspiring classroom learning in elementary schools using quality tools and techniques (i.e., cause and effect, continuous improvement, fishbone diagram, histogram, Pareto chart, root cause analysis, variation, etc.), and how to think through problems and use data effectively. She is a published poet and a writer of many articles in professional journals and magazines including CalLab, English Journal, Quality Progress, and Quality Digest.