Featured Product
This Week in Quality Digest Live
Health Care Features
Dirk Dusharme @ Quality Digest
Companies say they plan to pull some or all of their devices
Alex Waddell
Evidence points to what’s needed at individual and organizational levels
James Gaines
After decades of merely assisting doctors, are sophisticated machines ready to take charge?
Jon Speer
Fix issues that expose you to risk when it’s less expensive and time-consuming
Dirk Dusharme @ Quality Digest
First step, migrate your QMS to a cloud-based electronic quality management system

More Features

Health Care News
Easy, reliable leak testing with methylene blue
New medical product from Canon’s Video Sensing Division
Reduce identifying info in patient health data to enable better treatments and diagnostics
Making the new material freely available to testing laboratories and manufacturers worldwide
Google Docs collaboration, more efficient management of quality deviations
MIT course focuses on the impact of increased longevity on systems and markets
Delivers time, cost, and efficiency savings while streamlining compliance activity
First responders may benefit from NIST contest to reward high-quality incident command dashboards
Enhances clinical data management for medtech companies

More News

Vijay Iyer

Health Care

Lessons Learned From Using 3D-Printed Models to Improve Surgical Planning

Now physicians can experiment with different routes for endovascular procedures

Published: Monday, December 12, 2016 - 12:26

As the director of the structural heart team at Kaleida Health’s Gates Vascular Institute in Buffalo, New York, I perform minimally invasive, endovascular surgeries to repair structural defects of the heart. I specialize in valve replacements, clip procedures, and other structural heart treatments. Rather than cracking open the chest cavity to access the heart, I use blood vessels as conduits to deploy medical devices for these endovascular procedures. The ability to practice on realistic models is extremely valuable.

Vascular flow models are created by biomedical engineers. They take computed tomography (CT) scans or medical images of a patient’s heart and convert them into the type of file that is uploaded onto a 3D printer to create an accurate multidimensional anatomy. This conversion process can be performed in a matter of hours and we are looking for ways to accelerate it.

Using 3D printers is currently the best way to replicate patient-specific anatomy. We 3D print vascular flow models, sometimes called vascular phantoms, to simulate mechanical properties of blood vessels, tissue, and calcifications that allow us to “see” if navigation and vessel perforation is possible. The Jacobs Institute, a nonprofit medical device innovation center, in partnership with the University at Buffalo’s Toshiba Stroke and Vascular Research Center, the Gates Vascular Institute, and Stratasys, uses a Stratasys Objet500 Connex3 3D Printer to produce the multimaterial vascular models with rubberlike, polyurethane blend materials that have different material properties. The models simulate structural heart as well as neuro-, cardio-, and peripheral-vascular procedures. Biomedical engineers prepare the patient-specific models using CT scans or other medical images which are converted to 3D printable files.

Advantages of 3D-printed models over alternative methods

Before 3D-printed vascular flow models, planning for surgery essentially entailed looking at 3D reconstructions from patients’ CT scans on the computer and trying to imagine how the devices would fit. Because it was difficult to extrapolate all of the necessary information from these 3D reconstructions, adaptations had to be made on the fly during the procedures themselves. This both lengthened the procedure time and added another element of uncertainty. While cadavers offer the opportunity to practice deploying devices, they do not mirror the anatomy of specific patients, nor do they feel like living vessels, as the vessels are formalin fixed.

Using the 3D-printed heart model for surgical planning

Simulated Cath Lab Setup To Pre-Plan

Simulated cath lab setup to pre-plan

Now 3D-printed models can be hooked up to a “pump” that simulates blood flow and allows for physicians to experiment with different routes for endovascular procedures. Using 3D-printed vascular models to plan complex surgeries contributes to procedure success and better outcomes for high-risk patients, especially when I am using a new device or an off-label device. As each patient and situation is unique, being able to test a device on a 3D model prior to a complex procedure allows physicians to understand the potential interactions of the device with the patient’s tissue, as well as how the device will sit in the space. All of this information allows me to individualize surgical strategies.

What I learned from a pulmonic valve-in-valve replacement

In a recent pulmonic valve-in-valve replacement, based on computer based imaging, I was planning to proceed from the right femoral vein through the right atrium, right ventricle and then through the RV outflow tract atrium into the pulmonic valve. However, during the dry-run on the 3D-printed model of the patient’s heart, the device buckled in the right atrium when we tried this course. Based on this feedback, we adapted our plan and used a stiffer wire so it provided a tighter rail.

In terms of future improvements, the models need to be more predictable with better tissue characteristics so they respond to devices as real tissue would. It is probable that better imaging will lead to better models and that we will be able to make more accurate models using multiple modalities (CT, Echo, MRI) of the structures.

While the models are extremely helpful planning and practicing complex procedures, they do not need to be used for routine day-to-day cases as they are not without cost both in terms of materials and time.

Learn how to plan and implement your own 3D-printed surgical modelling program with this complimentary white paper.


About The Author

Vijay Iyer’s picture

Vijay Iyer

Vijay Iyer, M.D., is a board certified interventional cardiologist and the medical director for cardiac services at the Buffalo General Medical Center. Iyer believes it’s the physician’s responsibility to educate patients in a straightforward and open manner about the different treatment modalities. Iyer trains residents and cardiology fellows, mentors their research projects, and oversees cardiology fellows in outpatient settings. His research interests are in new devices for aortic and mitral valve replacement, novel therapeutics in the form of stem cells, and newer therapies for acute coronary syndromes.